The short answer: choose the agency that can show you, in plain English, how its work will turn into enquiries and bookings, that understands how travel buyers behave, and that can tell you where your brand stands in AI search today, not just on Google. If an agency can’t do those in the first conversation, keep looking.
That’s the answer. The rest of this article covers the questions to ask, the red flags to walk away from, and what good looks like.
Why this decision goes wrong so often
You get three proposals. Three definitions of SEO. Three prices that don’t compare like for like. One promises guaranteed rankings. Another quotes per link. The third hides its scope in a 47-slide deck.
The person making the call usually isn’t an SEO specialist, and shouldn’t have to be. Before I started Ink, I led SEO in-house at Ocean Holidays across three travel brands, so I’ve sat on the buying side of this too.
Six questions to ask
1. How will you report on this? Ask for a sample report. You want results by destination or trip page, tied to enquiries and bookings, not a dashboard of impressions.
2. What will you do in the first 30 days? A good agency can tell you. Expect an audit, a short list of priorities and a plan for the pages that make you the most money.
3. How do you plan around our trading calendar? Travel has peaks, long research windows and late bookers. Content and fixes need to land before demand, not during it.
4. Where do we stand in AI search today? Ask them to show you which brands ChatGPT and Google’s AI Overviews recommend for your trips, and why. If they can’t, they aren’t working on it yet.
5. Who will actually do the work? Meet the people, not just the pitch team.
6. What results have you got for brands like us? Look for travel case studies with commercial numbers, not just rankings.
Red flags
• Guaranteed rankings. No one controls Google or ChatGPT.
• Pricing by the link. Links matter, but buying them by the dozen isn’t a strategy.
• Jargon you couldn’t repeat to your MD.
• Reports that never mention enquiries or revenue.
What good looks like
Reporting your director can defend in a board meeting. Rankings that drive enquiries. Traffic that converts. And a clear view of how AI search sees your brand next to your competitors.
We rank first on Google for “travel SEO agency” and won Best Use of Search in Travel and Leisure at the UK Search Awards 2025, and we hold ourselves to the same six questions.
If you’d like a starting point before you speak to any agency, we’ll benchmark your brand against your competitors in AI search for free.